Expanding the Canada Pension Plan: Myths Debunked

December 18, 2015

[[{“fid”:”498″,”view_mode”:”default”,”fields”:{“format”:”default”,”field_file_image_alt_text[und][0][value]”:”coins”,”field_file_image_title_text[und][0][value]”:”coins”},”type”:”media”,”link_text”:null,”attributes”:{“alt”:”coins”,”title”:”coins”,”height”:”401″,”width”:”532″,”class”:”media-element file-default”}}]]

Myth #1: The economy is too fragile to increase CPP contributions now

The last time CPP contributions were increased was 1997. During the entire seven years the increase was phased in, employment rose and the economy steadily grew – and that time benefits to workers weren’t even increased. 

Myth #2: The Canada Pension Plan is a job-killing tax. 

CPP contributions are not a tax. They are savings put aside in return for a pension benefit in retirement. They are an investment by workers and their employers into a pension plan that is safe and sound. The savings in the CPP will eventually be spent in 10, 20 and 30 years, and will help create jobs in the future.

Corporations have more than enough room to contribute to expanding the CPP, which will provide greater future retirement benefits for today’s workers. Companies outside the banking industry have seven times as much cash in the bank than they did last time CPP contributions were raised. Businesses’ income tax has also dropped 13 percentage points since the 1990s.

Myth #3: Millions of jobs will be lost if CPP premiums are increased.

Increasing CPP premiums has never cost us jobs. In fact, people with better pensions will be able to spend more in their retirement – and that spending creates jobs. 

Myth #4: Small businesses are against an expansion of CPP.

Small businesses know that CPP is the best value for their money with its low management costs, portability and security. As self-employed workers, owners are contributing and benefiting from CPP. Expanding the CPP gives small business owners the risk-free stability of a defined-contribution savings plan, and a guaranteed defined-benefit pension plan for their workers. A poll of small businesses in Ontario showed that a majority of small and medium-sized businesses favoured an expanded CPP.

Related Articles

Canada’s unions say they hope finance ministers are fixing CPP inequities

Canada’s unions say they are encouraged that Canada’s finance ministers are working to strengthen the Canada Pension Plan and hope that means parents who take time off work to raise children and workers with disabilities will not be penalized. A statement issued by Canada’s finance ministers today promises “to provide greater benefits to parents whose income drops after the birth…
Read More

Canada’s unions celebrate adoption of CPP expansion legislation

Canada’s unions are celebrating today’s adoption by the House of Commons of Bill C-26, a legislation that will expand the Canada Pension Plan for the first time in the plan’s history. “Winning a stronger CPP has been a key priority for us for years and is an excellent example of the good that can come from collaborative work between unions…
Read More

Canada’s unions call anti-pension bill C-27 a betrayal

Canada’s unions are organizing against Bill C-27 a new piece of federal legislation that enables Crown corporations and federal private-sector employers to back out of defined-benefit pension commitments. “This bill was announced without consultation or advance notice, though it directly contradicts election promises to stabilize and improve retirement security,” said CLC President Hassan Yussuff, who wrote a letter to Finance Minister…
Read More